which is the factor that affects brightness of that bulb, current in the circuit or the voltage

Both. It's the power that ultimately causes the filament to get hot and emit visible black body radiation.

Power is voltage times current, so both matter.

However, you can only control one degree of freedom. The bulb dictates the other. This single degree of freedom can be expressed various ways. Two of them are fixing the current and fixing the voltage. Once you fix one of these, the resistance of the bulb implicitly fixes the other.

Note that the resistance of a bulb varies considerably with temperature. It is much higher when the bulb is emitting light than when it is sitting cold and unpowered. However, that still doesn't let you fix both independently. It only means that the relationship between voltage and current changes with the set point.

Answer from Olin Lathrop on Stack Exchange
Top answer
1 of 4
6
which is the factor that affects brightness of that bulb, current in the circuit or the voltage

Both. It's the power that ultimately causes the filament to get hot and emit visible black body radiation.

Power is voltage times current, so both matter.

However, you can only control one degree of freedom. The bulb dictates the other. This single degree of freedom can be expressed various ways. Two of them are fixing the current and fixing the voltage. Once you fix one of these, the resistance of the bulb implicitly fixes the other.

Note that the resistance of a bulb varies considerably with temperature. It is much higher when the bulb is emitting light than when it is sitting cold and unpowered. However, that still doesn't let you fix both independently. It only means that the relationship between voltage and current changes with the set point.

2 of 4
2

If you think of the lighting element, which may be a length of tungsten or the like, as a fixed resistor of R ohms, the current in the resistor is determined by:

Ohm's Law. The higher the voltage v the higher the current. If the brightness is caused by a flow of electrons through the filament, a higher voltage will--all things being equal-- drive more electrons to flow through the filament.

So the brightness is a function of both current and voltage, and can be said to depend on both. That is, we can write or

We might be tempted to say that the intensity I of the light is proportional to current, but we would have to remember that is a function of and put

This can get arbitrarily complicated, since intensity of the light may not be proportional to current in a simple way, and the precise behavior of electrons in a circuit depends on the exact conditions and the nature of the components. For example, as comments below note, the resistance may not be constant, but may be a function of temperature.

An accessible article on how resistance may vary in a light bulb is given here. A plot of I vs. V shows that the resistance R is not in general constant. To characterize the circuit in terms of V and I you might have to solve or take some measurements to get a quantitative idea.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/nostupidquestions › what affects a lightbulb's brightness, current or voltage?
r/NoStupidQuestions on Reddit: What affects a lightbulb's brightness, Current or Voltage?
November 20, 2019 -

I read about this online and they say its the Power that affects brightness, so it's actually both Current and Voltage. However, when I connected a bunch of lightbulbs together, they had the same brightness when they were connected in parallel regardless of how many lightbulbs I added (even though the current is being split across them so they should be having less power) and when I connected them in series they were less bright for each lightbulb I added.

🌐
Quora
quora.com › Does-a-light-bulbs-brightness-depend-on-voltage-or-current
Does a light bulb's brightness depend on voltage or current? - Quora
Answer (1 of 29): It's not one or the other, but both. Given the thermal characteristics of the resistance of tungsten, filament brightness is much more sensitive to current than it is to voltage. The filament is basically a black body radiator, and its light output depends strongly on the temp...
🌐
UW-Green Bay
uwgb.edu › fenclh › problems › electricity-magnetism › 12
Conceptual Circuit II - Physics - University of Wisconsin-Green Bay
No. The brightness of a lightbulb is given by its power. P = I2R, and so brightness depends on current and resistance. If the bulbs are identical, they have the same resistance. They may not, however, experience the same current.
🌐
IOPSpark
spark.iop.org › power-and-brightness-bulbs
Power and brightness of bulbs | IOPSpark
The brightness is the result of two electrical factors: ... To make this concrete, let's start with a circuit, in which a 12 volt battery is connected to a single bulb: This circuit is similar to that suggested for the big circuit in episode 01, where a car headlamp bulb was connected to a 12 volt supply. Assume that an ammeter connected into the circuit shows a current of 2 ampere and start by thinking about the bulb:
🌐
Homework.Study.com
homework.study.com › explanation › what-affects-the-brightness-of-a-bulb-current-or-voltage.html
What affects the brightness of a bulb current or voltage? | Homework.Study.com
What happens to the brightness of light emitted by a light bulb when the current in the filament increases? What happens to the amount of power a light bulb uses if the resistance of the bulb is increased? In fluorescent lamp when voltage increases current also increases.
Top answer
1 of 7
37

LEDs are a very very different beast compared to incandescent light bulbs. LEDs belong to a class of device known as non-linear devices. These don't follow Ohm's Law in the classic sense (however Ohm's Law is still used in conjunction with them).

An LED is (obviously) a form of diode. It has a forward voltage which is the voltage at which the diode starts to conduct. As the voltage increases so does how well the diode conducts, but it does that in a non-linear fashion.

              

With an LED it's the amount of current flowing through it that determines how bright it is. Increasing the voltage increases the current, yes, but the region where that happens without the current getting too much is very small. In the red curve above it may be that tiny little bit around 1.5V, and by the time you get to 2V the current is off the scale and the LED burns out.

Putting LEDs in series does sum the forward voltages, so you have to provide a higher voltage for conduction to start, but the controllable region is still just as tiny.

So we control the current instead of the voltage, and take the forward voltage as a fixed value. By either including a resistor in the circuit to fill the gap between the supply voltage and the forward voltage, limiting the current in the process, or by using a constant current supply, we can set the current that we want to flow through the LED and thus set the brightness. By increasing the current, but not increasing the voltage (or only a negligible amount, and purely incidentally), we increase the brightness.

The formula for calculating the resistance to use for a specific current is:

Where \ is the supply voltage, \ is the LED forward voltage, and \ is the desired LED forward current.

2 of 7
12

No, an LED by itself (no resistors or other electronics) behaves quite differently from a light bulb.

Have a look at this datasheet of a random LED.

Scroll down to the page with many graphs. The third graph shows the relative intensity (light) versus current through the LED:

(Source: 334-15/T1C1-4WYA datasheet)

You'll notice that this curve is somewhat linear, meaning twice the current would give you roughly twice as much light.

What have we learned: a LED's brightness is somewhat proportional to the current flowing through it.

But what current do you get for a certain voltage ?

Look at graph 2:

(Source: 334-15/T1C1-4WYA datasheet)

Forward current vs forward voltage, notice how the current increases rapidly for a voltage above 3 Volt. Only 0.5 V more gives 4 x the current! This curve also changes between LEDs and over temperature.

That is why it is better to feed LEDs with a current instead of a voltage. If you feed a LED a with voltage, the current is not very predictable so neither is the brightness. Also the power fed to the LED will then vary as Power is voltage x current.

It is better to keep a LED at a constant current so that is why series resistors are needed, these limit the current to the intended value. Not exactly but close enough for most purposes.

With the series resistor in place a LED (+ resistor) somewhat behave more like a lightbulb in the sense that the change in brightness is more proportional to the voltage you apply.

Find elsewhere
🌐
LED & Lighting Info
ledlightinginfo.com › brightness-of-the-bulb
What Determines The Brightness Of The Bulb? - LED & Lighting Info
May 7, 2023 - First of all, the bulb’s brightness, light (and heat) energy, depends on the power being input into the bulb. And power, measured in watts, is the voltage and current product, that is, power = Voltage x Current, P=VI.
🌐
The Student Room
thestudentroom.co.uk › showthread.php
What quantity affects the brightness in a bulb? - The Student Room
So current is determined by voltage and resistance in a real world application. The following is not required to answer a GCSE/A-level question. It does however show why there is difficulty in interpreting the OP's question: Chapmouse is correct in identifying that standard light bulbs are ...
🌐
YouTube
youtube.com › watch
Brightness and Power in Bulbs - YouTube
A common question in Physics 2 courses is to predict brightness of bulbs based on power in different series or parallel configurations. If you remember the ...
Published   October 28, 2020
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › classical physics › electromagnetism
Light Brightness Relationship with Potential and Current • Physics Forums
January 13, 2014 - If Potential = Constant*, bulb with LOWER RESISTANCE = Brighter (since I is higher from V=IR) If potential is a constant, and bulb resistance changes, then the power dissipated is P=v^2/R ... so a higher resistance means a lower power dissipation, so brightness is inversely proportional to resistance. i.e. you got the right relationship out the end. I'm a bit iffy about saying that this is because the current has increased - Ohms law describes a quantitative relationship not cause and effect. That must be inferred from other factors. Certainly if the voltage remains the same, and the current increased, the resistance must have decreased.
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › homework help › introductory physics homework help
Current, voltage : brightness of bulb in parallel or series
September 18, 2017 - For the same voltage (PUSH) it does not resist the passage of current (because it has low resistance) so becomes bright. The relevant equation is P =IV Say for Bulb A the current passing through is 6 A with a voltage (PUSH) of 10 V so the power the bulb receives to light the bulb is P=IV P = 6 x 10 P = 60 watts [THAT'S A BRIGHT BULB] Say for Bulb B the current passing through is only 1 A (because of its higher resistance) with a voltage (PUSH) of 10 V so the power the bulb receives to light the bulb is P=IV P = 1 x 10 P = 10 watts [THAT'S A DIM BULB]Q2.
🌐
BlueTree Education
bluetreeeducation.com › home › primary/ psle science: what affects the brightness of a bulb?
Primary/ PSLE Science: What affects the brightness of a bulb? - BlueTree Education
May 22, 2023 - The bulbs arranged in parallel arrangement will be brighter than bulbs in series arrangement. The number of bulbs added to an electric circuit will determine how bright the bulbs will light up.
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › engineering › electrical engineering
Can increasing voltage or current make a bulb brighter? • Physics Forums
May 13, 2007 - So the amperage will be dependent on the voltage and resistance via i=v/r. Yes, you can generally increase/decrease the brightness of an incandescent bulb by varying the voltage you put across it, which changes the amperage pushed through it.
🌐
Brainly
brainly.in › physics › secondary school
What determines the brightness of a light bulb current or voltage? - Brainly.in
July 28, 2023 - The brightness of a lightbulb is given by its power. P = I2R, and so brightness depends on current and resistance. If the bulbs are identical, they have the same resistance.
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › homework help › introductory physics homework help
How to determine the brightness of a light bulb • Physics Forums
February 25, 2007 - The brightness of a light bulb is influenced by both current and voltage, with power being the key measure of brightness. While more current and less resistance generally lead to increased brightness, the configuration of the circuit plays a ...
🌐
Homework.Study.com
homework.study.com › explanation › the-brightness-of-the-bulb-depends-on-a-current-b-voltage-c-both-a-and-b-d-none-of-the-above.html
The brightness of the bulb depends on ________. (a) current (b) voltage (c) Both (a) and (b) (d) None of the above. | Homework.Study.com
A certain light bulb is rated at 60.0 W when operating at the rms voltage of 120 V. A) What is the peak voltage applied across the bulb? B) What is the resistance of the bulb? A 9 V battery supplies a current of 0.25 A to the bulb of a torch. What is the power rating of the bulb? When a light bulb is connected to a 9 V battery, it draws 1.1 A of current. An identical light bulb is connected in series to the first. What does this say about the brightness of the bulb relative to when there was only one in the circuit?
🌐
Physics Forums
physicsforums.com › other physics topics
Brightness of a Bulb: Power vs. Current Explained • Physics Forums
April 29, 2011 - The brightness of a bulb is primarily determined by power, which is the product of current and voltage (P = IV), and increasing either current or voltage will increase brightness.