🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/electricvehicles › are teslas really the "safest cars on the road"?
r/electricvehicles on Reddit: Are Teslas really the "safest cars on the road"?
February 2, 2023 -

This is something I hear from people occasionally, but is it true, or are they just the safest cars for their size and weight? If a Ford F350 and a Tesla Model 3 crashed head-on, would the Tesla occupants sustain less injuries? After all, the Ford F350 has a significant amount of size and weight on its side. One might say it's not fair to compare vehicles of different weight classes, but I would say it's important to consider the reality of crash scenarios on the road. Ultimately, the safety of a vehicle depends on several factors, such as its design, construction, and equipped safety features. While Teslas have received high safety ratings and have some advanced safety features, I don't believe it's accurate to say they are the safest cars on the road without considering the context of the crash scenario and the comparison to other vehicles in different weight classes.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/electricvehicles › tesla vs other evs for safety
r/electricvehicles on Reddit: Tesla vs other EVs for safety
January 30, 2024 -

Just as the title says. Is the Tesla technology the best and safest or are there other EVs that are close to or taking the upper hand?

Top answer
1 of 5
32
What kind of safety? The EU's NCAP is an unbiased source that focuses on things like occupant safety, pedestrian safety, child safety and also electronic avoidance systems: https://www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-rewards/best-in-class-cars/2022/ Do note that Tesla cars only show up when the first model year after a change (Model 3 only shows up in 2019, Model S & Y only shows up in 2022). It's just how they do the list. But I'd say Tesla is near the top of this NCAP list if not consistently at the top. https://www.euroncap.com/en/ratings-rewards/best-in-class-cars/2022/ Tesla Model S Hyundai IONIQ 6 GWM Wey 05 (Coffee 01) GWM ORA 03 (Funky Cat) Tesla Model Y That's the "best in class" for all cars in 2022. Here is 2019: - Tesla Model 3 - BMW 3 Series - Tesla Model X - Mercedes-Benz CLA - Subaru Forester - Renault Clio - Audi A1 Here is NCAP's statement in 2022 (the most recent year): Tesla has made a huge impact on the European car market due to its design and ethos. The company has also been determined to make a name for its brand in safety performance. Tesla Model S and Tesla Model Y are both high achievers in Adult Occupant Protection and both vehicles achieved the highest score of 98% in Safety Assist of all the vehicles in this list. Tesla Model S is also the best in class achiever in the Pure Electric category. The highest ever rating in "adult occupant safety" is a 98% by a Tesla Model X. The next highest is a VW ID.7 at 97% and a NIO ET5 at 96%. The highest rating for child safety is a few Mercedes models and Subaru Forester 90%-91%. Tesla tends closer an above average 82-85% for that score. The highest ever rating for "pedestrian safety" went to a Mazda. Tesla, Toyota and Lexus and Mercedes make up the rest of the top of that list. For "Driver Assistance", Tesla scores WAY above the competition with a 98% . GWM, NIO and Mercedes (and a couple new BMWs) also score in the 90s. So according to NCAP for the EU market, I'd say its: Tesla GWM Mercedes BMW Toyota/Lexus
2 of 5
19
The Tesla Model Y is... "Best in Class" according to EuroNCAP. "Top Safety Pick+" according to IIHS. 5 stars in all categories and subcategories according to NHTSA.
🌐
Substack
philkoopman.substack.com › p › debunking-tesla-safest-car-on-the
Debunking Tesla "Safest Car On The Road" claims
November 23, 2024 - Look at all the articles bashing Tesla and over time you see the same sources. Almost all of your points have been debunked. You do not understand that no other automobiles have and have had the tech in the millions of Tesla on the road.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamotors › how the tesla model 3 became the world’s safest car
r/teslamotors on Reddit: How the Tesla Model 3 became the world’s safest car
March 31, 2019 -

How the Tesla Model 3 became the world’s safest car

He shows how the very aspect of having a flat battery floor and a glass roof that is supported by a solid frame makes the car safer.

That the glass roof is actually stronger than sheet metal, but how it breaks distributes energy away from passengers unlike a sheet metal roof that collapses into passengers.The floor, makes all Teslas extremely hard to flip, and allows for the chassis to have much better crumple zones that again, distribute energy away from passengers.

He then shows how a Tesla model 3 that was hit in a side impact at 70mph and made for one of the extremely rare cases of flipping still resulted in only minor injuries to person in the model 3.Additionally he shows many crash prevention features that of course were not part of the NTSA rating review as they are preventative.

One key one... the emergency lane departure, yes many cars now have this... but I note it as the very feature that would have prevented the accident I was in as an infant were an uncle flipped his VW Beattle off the freeway with us in it.

One feature no other car has...

A Tesla can see through several cars ahead and behind. So if a car you cannot see suddenly stops or wrecks, your car tells you in time to react before the cars in front of you drive into a pileup. I have been the middle car in a pileup before... my car then was stopped so this wouldn’t have protected me, but it would have protected 3 of the 4 behind me if they had been Teslas, and that in turn would have stopped them from hitting me...

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cars › tesla has the highest fatal accident rate of all car brands, study finds
r/cars on Reddit: Tesla Has the Highest Fatal Accident Rate of All Car Brands, Study Finds
November 15, 2024 - They are safe, not the safest kind of anything ever, but great rollover resistance, lots of space for crumple zones, etc. The study’s authors make clear that the results do not indicate Tesla vehicles are inherently unsafe or have design flaws.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamodel3 › tesla is the safest car!
r/TeslaModel3 on Reddit: Tesla is the safest car!
December 11, 2021 -

This morning I was.driving to office with some pretty loud music and I was barely paying attention. ( yes, I am at wrong here ). While I was trying to change lane, there was a car on my blind spot and when I tried to change the lane, Tesla made that annoying sound of lane departure and red flashing on screen. Basically it didn't allow me to change lane even though I tried hard to steer left. It would have been 💯 accident in any other car.. I will be paying more attention while driving next time but thanks for Tesla tech!!

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamodely › i'm sold. tesla is the safest car on the road
r/TeslaModelY on Reddit: I'm sold. Tesla is the safest car on the road
June 17, 2025 -

We've had our Model Y for just about a year now. It's been a blast to drive, we've already put 13k miles on it in 11 months, FSD is incredible, and we find ourselves using it significantly more than our other ICE car. However today I was officially fully sold on its safety aspects. I was driving home from running some errands, when I wasn't paying attention for a split second to grab something off of the seat, And another car came pulling out of their driveway without looking at all. By the time I looked up to see a car directly in front of me, the Tesla had already initiated the brakes and started stopping by itself. Had the Tesla not been in control, and I had been driving an older non smart car, I 100% would have T boned the guy and had lots of damage. The Tesla software 100% saved me

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/technology › tesla has highest rate of deadly accidents among car brands, study finds
r/technology on Reddit: Tesla Has Highest Rate of Deadly Accidents Among Car Brands, Study Finds
August 16, 2024 - Despite Tesla's claims that its vehicles are the safest in the world, a study by iSeeCars indicates that Tesla has the highest rate of fatal accidents among car brands, with 5.6 deadly crashes per billion miles, just slightly higher than Kia.
Find elsewhere
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslalounge › is tesla still hold high safety ratings? (need ammo for wife)
r/TeslaLounge on Reddit: Is Tesla still hold high safety ratings? (Need ammo for wife)
February 1, 2023 -

When we bought the car, I would tell my wife how Tesla Model Y has the highest safety ratings, It's one of the safest cars for our family, so on. She's a bit of a Tesla hater and was asking me for some documentation that shows that it's the safest car. I did a quick Google search and I find a few articles from Tesla, which she says is biased. I searched Euro NCAP thing and found that it's on the top but not #1. Is there any reliable articles I could point her to so she can see that it is one of the safest cars? Or does it no longer hold that rating? Thanks!

EDIT: Thanks for all the info. She now knows it's legit. Thanks.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamotors › exactly. a tesla is objectively much safer in a crash than all other cars, according to nhtsa’s *own* calculations. this is just physics!
r/teslamotors on Reddit: Exactly. A Tesla is objectively much safer in a crash than all other cars, according to NHTSA’s *own* calculations. This is just physics!
October 12, 2018 - They produce vertically integrated electric vehicles, batteries, solar, and AI software and hardware solutions. ... Tesla Model 3 is now the safest new car on the market thanks to its overall Euro NCAP score of 359 out of 400
🌐
Tesla
tesla.com › VehicleSafetyReport
Tesla Vehicle Safety Report | Tesla
It’s this notion that grounds ... offer every Tesla owner. Model S, Model 3, Model X and Model Y have achieved among the lowest overall probability of injury of any vehicles ever tested by the U.S....
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamodely › do you guys know the real secret of why model y is the safest car?
r/TeslaModelY on Reddit: Do you guys know the real secret of why Model Y is the safest car?
December 9, 2023 -

The initial design is impeccable, and there's a promise of even better aesthetics in the future.

Tesla's alerting technology continues to advance each day, addressing occasional bugs promptly through constant monitoring and immediate fixes.

Beyond the inherent safety features, regenerative braking adds a notable safety advantage. Upon closer consideration, two safety scenarios become apparent, possibly familiar to many Tesla owners.

Firstly, the "use on demand" concept mandates continuous pressure on the accelerator pedal to move forward. This not only encourages driver attentiveness but also discourages drowsiness behind the wheel.

The second advantage becomes evident during emergency braking situations. The moment the accelerator pedal is released, regenerative braking initiates, providing a preemptive braking effect before the traditional brakes are applied.

As for a potential third scenario, I'll leave that open for discussion in the comments section, inviting others to share their perspectives.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/electricvehicles › tesla model y achieves the highest euro ncap safety scores ever recorded.
r/electricvehicles on Reddit: Tesla Model Y achieves the highest EURO NCAP safety scores ever recorded.
November 21, 2025 -

Top 3 cars by total score by EURO NCAP.

  • 2025 Tesla Model Y — 362 (highest)

  • 2025 Tesla Model 3 — 359

  • 2025 smart #5 — 357

Worth to note that Euro NCAP does not test all cars. It chooses which cars it wants to test, usually focusing on new, high-volume, or important models, but manufacturers must cooperate by providing the cars.

Tesla full report https://preview.thenewsmarket.com/Previews/NCAP/DocumentAssets/707952.pdf

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamotors › a detailed analysis of tesla safety and accident data
r/teslamotors on Reddit: A detailed analysis of Tesla safety and accident data
May 27, 2023 -

In light of recent headlines and articles, some of which contain blatantly false claims or badly misrepresented data, I conducted a thorough review of the available data about both safety testing AND accident rates, with receipts.

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslalounge › are teslas actually dangerous in a crash?
r/TeslaLounge on Reddit: Are Teslas actually dangerous in a crash?
April 12, 2025 -

I keep seeing stuff online about Teslas being risky if you crash—like the doors won’t open if there’s no power, or the battery can catch fire and it’s hard to put out. Is this legit, or just internet fearmongering? Anyone here have real experience (good or bad) with Tesla safety in an accident? Curious what the community thinks.

🌐
Wshapiro
wshapiro.com › home › blog › how dangerous are teslas? the truth behind the headlines
How Dangerous Are Teslas? The Truth Behind the Headlines | William D. Shapiro Law, Inc.
November 12, 2025 - Teslas are the safest cars on the road,” Tesla CEO Elon Musk boldly claimed on X (formerly Twitter) last year. It’s a statement that reflects Tesla’s self-assured branding, emphasizing cutting-edge engineering and advanced safety features.
Price   $$$
Address   893 East Brier Dr., 92408, San Bernardino
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/electricvehicles › what are the objectively good/bad things about tesla vehicles (sans cybertruck)
r/electricvehicles on Reddit: What are the objectively good/bad things about Tesla vehicles (sans Cybertruck)
March 3, 2025 -

Hi everyone I'm Greyson

I live in LA and it seems to me that Tesla's are everywhere. They're no longer for stuffy tech bros, they just seem like a somewhat expensive standard full EV.

Personally I don't hate Tesla as much as others, I think the cars in general look sleek and stylish, and they are at the moment distinctive on the road, not to speak about their drivers...

I haven't done much research, but from what people talk about online, they say that Tesla's are often poorly built and hard to service. I imagine repairing EVs is much different than IC engines which I'm more familiar with.

But overall I don't know what to think since I don't own one. I don't see a lot of wrecked Tesla's, I don't hear my family talking about how they break down or get scuffed easily (the more wealthy side of my family owns a few, but not the Cybertruck which they describe as a waste of money).

So I'd like to ask you guys what are the good and bad from Tesla, economic and political issues included, I wanna hear it all.

Are there just better things in the market, or is Tesla big standard in terms of EVs?

Thank you for reading,

Greyson

🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/teslamotors › tesla model y receives top safety pick+ rating with nearly perfect score
r/teslamotors on Reddit: Tesla Model Y Receives Top Safety Pick+ Rating With Nearly Perfect Score
December 13, 2022 - I thought I remembered reading that it was the safest SUV at least at one point. ... Before the Y came out Elon said safety was X > S > 3, presumably because of differences in size and mass* ... The IIHS and the NHTSA pay for the cars tested. Low volume Luxury or performance vehicles don't always get tested. ... The agencies choose mainstream cars, however manufacturers can specifically request a test which is how the Ghibli got on there. At the time I remember speculation that Tesla requested the S get tested but did not request the X get tested because they were worried about the overlap test results.
🌐
TESLARATI
teslarati.com › home › news › tesla named as one of world’s safest car brands: uk study
Tesla named as one of world’s safest car brands: UK study
January 23, 2025 - Based on its analysis, Volvo, Subaru, Tesla, Genesis, and Polestar came out as the top five safest car brands in the world.