🌐
BabyGearLab
babygearlab.com › vehicle safety › car seat reviews
The 10 Best Car Seats | Crash Tested
Nuna Pipa RX
Convertible car seats are perfect for older babies and toddlers with a more upright posture and useful features. Credit: Abriah Wofford · Convertible seats are for older babies (around nine months) and can last until your little one is about 3-7 years old, depending on the model and your child's size. The seat starts facing the vehicle seat or backward (the safest ... After spending tens of thousands of dollars on crash testing car seats in a certified testing lab, we discovered that not all car seats are equal, despite...
Rating: 4.9 ​
🌐
Consumer Reports
consumerreports.org › babies & kids › baby & toddler › car seats
Car Seats via @ConsumerReports
We test and rate 100+ car seats so that we can make clear recommendations—and you can easily find the right fit.
Discussions

Safest infant seat recommendations
When used correctly, it is entirely safe to bring a baby home from the hospital in a convertible such as the 4Ever. That said, there are a couple of things to consider: Hospital policy may make things challenging. It’s true that some hospitals will make life very difficult for you if you don’t show up with an infant bucket seat. You should call your hospital and clarify. Often talking to the charge nurse in the postpartum wing will be your best bet. All-in-one car seats can just be overwhelming. There are at least 4 different modes of use on that seat, and frankly the learning curve to use it isn’t something I typically recommend to first time parents. This is an over-generalization but typically the newborn bucket seats are simpler. They only do one thing. So… while it’s ok to get the 4Ever if you want one, I’d say it’s even more important to visit with a CPST to learn how to use it before you bring the baby home, as well as planning to make follow up visits occasionally (especially at milestones like changing the mode of use) as the baby grows. The longer I work with families and car seats the less I’m a fan of the Swiss Army Knife style of car seats for this reason. They are, however, safe when used correctly. And, full disclosure, this is my personal opinion and does not reflect a general opinion among CPSTs. Now - in terms of the safest car seat - it’s whichever one fits your car, fits your child, and you can use correctly every time. This really is the truth. Yes, Nuna seats are great and usually very user friendly. But you should not feel like you have to spend that much to keep your child safe. The more important thing is to read your vehicle manual and your car seat manual, and reach out for clarification on anything you might need help on. You don’t mention what kind of car you drive. That could help us tailor recommendations for you. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/CPST
9
5
April 24, 2025
Please just tell me what car seat to buy
I love Graco Extend2Fit. Works well in my SUV you might vary in a sedan. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/toddlers
472
236
May 9, 2024
Most comfortable and safest convertible car seat?

https://m.albeebaby.com/cybex-sirona-s-sensorsafe-2-1-convertible-car-seat-indigo-blue.html

More on reddit.com
🌐 r/daddit
10
6
January 14, 2019
Safest convertible car seat for baby?
If you’re in the US, the organization you’re looking for is NHTSA, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, part of the federal Dept of Transportation. It’s the federal agency charged with vehicle safety, including car seats. They use standardized measures to test and rate car seats, and all car seats sold in the US meet their safety standards. They don’t even rate safety- it’s either a pass or a fail, in which case it can’t be sold. There are some car seats that might meet different safety standards in other countries, but in the US, any seat you buy will be fine. More on reddit.com
🌐 r/ScienceBasedParenting
65
30
July 28, 2022
🌐
NHTSA
nhtsa.gov › vehicle-safety › car-seats-and-booster-seats
Car Seat & Booster Seat Safety, Ratings, Guidelines | NHTSA
It has a harness and, in a crash, cradles and moves with your child to reduce the stress to the child's fragile neck and spinal cord. Find out how to install rear-facing car seats. Your child under age 1 should always ride in a rear-facing car seat.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/cpst › safest infant seat recommendations
r/CPST on Reddit: Safest infant seat recommendations
April 24, 2025 -

Hi, I’m a FTM and feeling a bit overwhelmed with the bigger baby purchases. My husband and I were looking at the Graco 4Ever Extend2Fit DLX 4-in-1 Car Seat, as it’s currently on sale in Costco, but as we were in line to checkout, a dad approached us inquiring if we intended to use that for our newborn, and recommended we shop at Target for a bucket seat instead, saying the hospital wouldn’t let us take our newborn home in the Graco.

We were also looking at the Nuna PIPA rx, but I saw a lot of recommendations on this subreddit for Graco, mentioning with Nuna you’re mainly paying for the style and name.

We don’t mind spending more on ensuring our babies comfort/safety, so the budget isn’t as much of a concern. What would you recommend is the safest/best car seat option for a newborn?

Top answer
1 of 5
12
When used correctly, it is entirely safe to bring a baby home from the hospital in a convertible such as the 4Ever. That said, there are a couple of things to consider: Hospital policy may make things challenging. It’s true that some hospitals will make life very difficult for you if you don’t show up with an infant bucket seat. You should call your hospital and clarify. Often talking to the charge nurse in the postpartum wing will be your best bet. All-in-one car seats can just be overwhelming. There are at least 4 different modes of use on that seat, and frankly the learning curve to use it isn’t something I typically recommend to first time parents. This is an over-generalization but typically the newborn bucket seats are simpler. They only do one thing. So… while it’s ok to get the 4Ever if you want one, I’d say it’s even more important to visit with a CPST to learn how to use it before you bring the baby home, as well as planning to make follow up visits occasionally (especially at milestones like changing the mode of use) as the baby grows. The longer I work with families and car seats the less I’m a fan of the Swiss Army Knife style of car seats for this reason. They are, however, safe when used correctly. And, full disclosure, this is my personal opinion and does not reflect a general opinion among CPSTs. Now - in terms of the safest car seat - it’s whichever one fits your car, fits your child, and you can use correctly every time. This really is the truth. Yes, Nuna seats are great and usually very user friendly. But you should not feel like you have to spend that much to keep your child safe. The more important thing is to read your vehicle manual and your car seat manual, and reach out for clarification on anything you might need help on. You don’t mention what kind of car you drive. That could help us tailor recommendations for you.
2 of 5
6
This is where you can find good info https://www.reddit.com/r/ConsumerAdvice/comments/1lfds24/infant_car_seats_for_you/
🌐
Car and Driver
caranddriver.com › home › parts, gear, tools, and accessories › tested: best convertible child car seats of 2026
Tested: Best Convertible Child Car Seats of 2026
December 17, 2025 - If your vehicle allows it and the seat fits securely, absolutely. The middle seat is often considered the safest spot in the car.
🌐
Graco Baby
gracobaby.com › shop › car-seats › toddler-car-seats › all-in-one-car-seats › 4ever-dlx-4-in-1-car-seat › SP_229437.html
4Ever® DLX 4-in-1 Car Seat | Graco Baby
4Ever® DLX 4-in-1 Car Seat
Graco® 4Ever® DLX 4-in-1 Car Seat gives you 10 years of use with one car seat. It’s the only car seat you'll ever need that goes from baby to booster, from 4–120 lb!
Price   $329.99
🌐
Safety 1st
safety1st.com
Safety 1st Official US Site | Car Seats, Strollers & Baby Gear
Official website for Safety 1st. Shop all-in-one car seats, convertible car seats, rotating car seats, boosters, high chairs, bassinets, strollers, travel systems, baby-proofing, infant health gear and more. Shop Now!
Find elsewhere
🌐
Nuna
nunababy.com › car seats
Nuna | Premium All-In-One Car Seats for Child Car Safety
Explore Nuna's collection of safe, ergonomic car seats for little ones. Premium, all-in-one car seats, convertible car seats & stylish boosters. Browse now.
🌐
CarseatBlog
carseatblog.com › safest-recommended-car-seats
Recommended Car Seats 2026 – CarseatBlog
December 17, 2025 - KeyFit 35 Features: 4-35 lbs.; up to 32″ tall; 5-position no-rethread harness, 1 buckle position; 6-position adjustable base with anti-rebound bar; unique center-pull lower LATCH anchor tightening adjustment; premium push-on lower anchor ...
🌐
Graco Baby
gracobaby.com › shop › car-seats
Explore Baby Car Seats | Shop Now | Graco Baby
Graco car seats are built with safety, comfort, and ease in mind, giving you peace of mind every time you hit the road. From infant to toddler and beyond, our seats grow with your child while fitting seamlessly into your everyday life.
🌐
Maxi-Cosi
maxicosi.com › home › car seats
Maxi Cosi Car Seats | Shop Infant & Toddler Car Seats from Maxi Cosi – Maxi-Cosi
Your baby deserves premium comfort and protection in the car, and the lineup of Maxi Cosi car seats delivers on that promise and so much more. Our selection of infant, convertible and belt-positioning boosters are adjustable to meet the specific ...
🌐
The Quality Edit
thequalityedit.com › parenting › parenting reviews › i tried 9 slim car seats – meet the two my family uses daily
What is the Best Slim Car Seat for My Child? (2025) | The Quality Edit
April 14, 2025 - As a parent with a compact car, I was really excited to try the Evenflo Revolve360 Slim 2-in-1 Rotational Car Seat. The 16.7” width is perfect for tight spaces, making it an ideal choice for anyone with a smaller vehicle. Despite its slim profile, it doesn’t skimp on comfort or safety.
🌐
Safety 1st
safety1st.com › home › car seats
Car Seats & Baby Car Safety Products | Safety 1st
Choose from convertible, booster and infant car seats that are designed to provide protection for your little one, so you can take comfort in knowing that your child is riding safe.
🌐
Nuna
nunababy.com › car seats › infant car seats
Nuna Infant Car Seats | FR-Free & Mindfully Manufactured
Nuna infant car seats are protective, elegantly styled, & mindfully crafted with naturally flame-resistant materials that are free from fire-retardant chemicals.
🌐
Chicco
chiccousa.com › choosing-a-car-seat › how-to-choose-a-car-seat
How to Choose the Best Car Seat for Your Child | Chicco
Whether you're expecting your very first baby or shopping for a lively toddler, every Chicco car seat is engineered for comfort, safety, and peace of mind. World-class innovation and user-friendly touchpoints make Chicco car seats reassuringly ...
🌐
NYTimes
nytimes.com › baby and kid › safety › the best booster car seats
The 4 Best Booster Car Seats of 2026 | Reviews by Wirecutter
November 20, 2025 - These seats are for school-age kids who are 40 pounds, as well as for those who are ready — both physically and developmentally — to graduate from a five-point harness seat. This attractive booster is safe, easy to use, and comfortable. It’s a hit with caregivers and kids alike.
🌐
Reddit
reddit.com › r/toddlers › please just tell me what car seat to buy
r/toddlers on Reddit: Please just tell me what car seat to buy
May 9, 2024 -

My 17 month old needs a new car seat and I am completely overwhelmed! Any recs of ones you love? I have sedan and I want it to be safe/be able to stay rear facing as long as possible that's my only preferences. There is so much on the market I get bogged down with all the choices and the reviews. Any recs would be amazing and help us so much!

Edit: thank you for all the answers wow! 3 months of using the graco extend to fit and love it! It fits fine in my sedan. I will note I only have 1 kiddo in the back seat so I don't notice/ mind it's size. It's super comfy for LO and aligns with my desire to keep rear facing as long as possible. Noting this in case anyone comes across this post also overwhelmed lol

🌐
Target
target.com › c › car-seats-baby › - › N-5xtlx
Car Seats : Target
When it’s time for older kids to transition, the booster car seat ensures proper belt positioning, keeping children safe and comfortable until they’re ready for a standard seat belt.
🌐
Safe Kids Worldwide
safekids.org › car-seat
Car Seat Safety Tips | Safe Kids Worldwide
Correctly used child safety seats can reduce the risk of death by as much as 71 percent. More than half of car seats are not used or installed correctly.