My husband and I recently bought the Kirkland Stearns and Foster Lakeridge mattress from Costco and we like it a lot. We are both mostly side sleepers and are pretty lightweight (120 and 135 pounds). While we like the plush firmness of the mattress, we wonder if we would be more comfortable with a topper. We are looking at the Serenity by Tempur-pedic topper from Costco but the reviews are mixed and it’s been hard to make a decision. For people that have this topper, what have been your experiences?

I bought this topper out of desperation and thank goodness I can return it!!!

Don't buy the Serenity by Tempur-Pedic topper. It's a piece of junk, joke! It tore everywhere just laying it on a table and trying to rotate it. Then, when I saw that, I carefully grabbed it to rotate it and move it to a different location and it ripped more! Basically, it rips anytime you touch it! The cover isn't actually a cover as you'd expect for this caliber of a topper. It's a rounded-edge fitted mattress only thicker. Because the corners of the mattress are pointed it just bunches on the corners and pulls the mattress upward. It's extremely difficult to get it on as it just pulls the whole other side and it curls up due to the low density so even with two people it was a LONG struggle! As you can imagine, putting a fitted sheet or mattress cover over it was even worse. It's just a poor fit! The 3 inches are non-existent when you lay down on it or even sit on it. In, fact, if you hold it between your thumb and index finger you can completely flatten it just with your fingertips! There is no density so you touch the ground but it puffs on the sides of you so you can't get up! I actually tried stacking two which was a total fail because I REALLY couldn't move and was stuck in the middle with my body on the hard floor and total puff on the sides. I feel pretty stupid thinking that stacking two soft toppers with no supportive layer would be a good idea! lol I'm a dedicated side sleeper but in desperation, I tried laying in all positions and none of them were good. I'm 176lbs for reference, but I feel like anything but an ant would sink to the bottom! The smell is STRONG!!! Honestly, it's super overpriced for what you get. I got a cheaper one at Target in the past that was better for more than half the price of this one. I'm truly shocked that a company with such a good reputation for mattresses would create something this poor of quality and even more by the reviews that said it was great to begin with!